Menu

10 Best Health Insurance Offices in Austin

This comparison covers Austin-area insurance offices with different areas of focus, from Medicare Supplement and Part D guidance to family, business, auto, and home coverage. Use the distinctions below to identify the kind of explanation, enrollment help, or policy support that fits your situation.

How we rank this list

This guide does not try to list everyone. It is our pick of health insurance offices in Austin, built on each business's public reputation and on how central this service is to what it does.

Featured positions are clearly marked and only offered to businesses that already earned their place in the guide.

Top 3All listingsMapHow to decide

Health Insurance Offices to Compare in Austin

Select one to see why it made the list.

#1
Abt Insurance Agency
5.0892 reviews
People approaching Medicare eligibility or comparing Medicare optionsClients who want patient explanations before selecting a plan
#2
Four Oaks Medicare Planning
5.0256 reviews
People new to MedicareHouseholds comparing Supplement and Part D coverageClients who want enrollment guidance explained step by step
#3
GoMedigap
4.91,987 reviews
People researching Medicare Supplement plansShoppers seeking help understanding Part D and coverage choices

Full Comparison of 10 Health Insurance Offices in Austin

Abt Insurance Agency, Austin#1
Strengths

  • Educational videos provide Medicare guidance before a consultation

  • Agents help with plan comparisons, questions and enrollment paperwork

Abt Insurance Agency

5.0892 reviews
2301 W Anderson Ln. Unit 129, Austin, TX 78757, United States
A good fit for
People approaching Medicare eligibility or comparing Medicare optionsClients who want patient explanations before selecting a plan

Abt Insurance Agency is an Austin insurance agency particularly suited to people navigating Medicare enrollment and coverage choices. Agents explain plan differences, answer questions over time and handle enrollment paperwork after clients choose an option. Educational YouTube videos and patient, non-pressured consultations make the agency useful for people who want to understand their choices before enrolling.

Four Oaks Medicare Planning, Austin#2
Strengths

  • Provides an organized process from first discussion through enrollment

  • Offers ongoing educational information through its blog and other resources

Four Oaks Medicare Planning

5.0256 reviews
5424 W US Hwy 290 Service Rd Ste 209, Austin, TX 78735, United States
A good fit for
People new to MedicareHouseholds comparing Supplement and Part D coverageClients who want enrollment guidance explained step by step

Four Oaks Medicare Planning is an Austin insurance broker focused on helping people understand Medicare choices, including Medicare Supplement, Part B and Part D coverage. Its process is organized from an initial discussion through enrollment, with guidance tailored to a household’s budget and needs. It suits people new to Medicare or anyone wanting a clear comparison of coverage options and drug-plan decisions.

GoMedigap, Austin#3
Strengths

  • Provides step-by-step explanations during plan research and enrollment

  • Offers ongoing annual plan reviews

GoMedigap

4.91,987 reviews
13620 Ranch Rd 620 N Ste A-250, Austin, TX 78717, United States
A good fit for
People researching Medicare Supplement plansShoppers seeking help understanding Part D and coverage choices

GoMedigap is an Austin health insurance agency that helps people compare and enroll in Medicare Supplement and Part D plans. It suits Medicare shoppers who want patient explanations, plan guidance, and assistance reviewing whether different coverage may be appropriate over time.

Starr Insurance Agency, Austin#4
Strengths

  • Can handle quote questions and policy adjustments directly with an agent

  • Supports multi-policy coverage including home, vehicle and umbrella insurance

Starr Insurance Agency

4.9251 reviews
8801 Research Blvd #104, Austin, TX 78758, United States
A good fit for
Customers comparing auto, home or umbrella coveragePeople needing help coordinating multiple insurance policies

Starr Insurance Agency is an Austin commercial insurance agent that helps customers compare coverage, prepare quotes and adjust policies. It suits people managing multiple policies, including home, vehicle and umbrella coverage, as well as customers seeking auto insurance. The agency’s service includes direct human assistance and detailed responses to coverage questions.

Simple Retirement Benefits, Austin#5
Strengths

  • Reviews prescription coverage and doctors’ network participation

  • Explains competing Medicare approaches without a reported sales pitch

Simple Retirement Benefits

5.099 reviews
8711 Burnet Rd Ste E50, Austin, TX 78757, United States
A good fit for
People evaluating Medicare Supplement or Advantage plansClients who need help comparing coverage, costs, and networks

Simple Retirement Benefits is an insurance agency offering online appointments and guidance through Medicare-related choices. Its planning support includes comparing Medicare Supplement and Advantage plans, reviewing prescription coverage, checking doctors’ networks, and weighing options against a household budget. It suits people who want patient explanations and multiple plan comparisons without being steered toward a particular provider.

Nemetz Insurance Services, Austin#6
Strengths

  • Explains coverage details and makes time for questions

  • Has assisted with Medicare, prescription and vision plans

  • Provides follow-up during application processing

Nemetz Insurance Services

4.9131 reviews
3470 Jack C Hays Trail Ste d, Buda, TX 78610, United States
A good fit for
Individuals comparing health insurance optionsPeople setting up Medicare and related coverageClients facing enrollment changes or complicated applications

Nemetz Insurance Services is a Buda health insurance agency that helps individuals, families and businesses evaluate coverage. Ron Nemetz explains policy details, answers questions and assists with applications, including Medicare and ancillary plans such as prescription and vision coverage. The service suits people facing enrollment deadlines, plan changes or complicated insurance decisions who want one person to guide the process.

HealthMarkets Insurance, Austin#7
Strengths

  • Consultations can take place in the office or at a client’s home

  • The agent is identified as licensed and Austin-based

HealthMarkets Insurance

4.953 reviews
A good fit for
Families comparing health insurance plansPeople who have recently lost coverageClients who want plan details explained in a guided consultation

HealthMarkets Insurance is an Austin-based licensed health insurance agent who helps individuals and families compare coverage options. Gabrielle Sones is presented as a guide through plan details and is available for meetings in an office or at a client’s home. The service suits people facing a coverage change or seeking help matching a plan to their family’s specific needs.

Heaton Bennett Insurance, Austin#8
Strengths

  • Independent agency representing multiple insurance carriers

  • Dedicated team support for personal and business insurance needs

Heaton Bennett Insurance

4.9981 reviews
3933 Steck Ave B119, Austin, TX 78759, United States
A good fit for
Austin households comparing auto or home coverageBusiness owners seeking commercial insurance or group health plans

Heaton Bennett Insurance is an independent Austin agency serving personal and business insurance needs. It compares coverage from a wide variety of carriers, with offerings that include auto, homeowners, condo, renters, landlord, motorcycle, boat, life, commercial and group health insurance. A dedicated team supports policy changes, claims, payments and proof-of-insurance requests.

Cedar Oak Insurance, Austin#9
Strengths

  • The agency can help coordinate auto, renters and pet coverage

  • The process is described as responsive and easy to navigate

Cedar Oak Insurance

4.9220 reviews
901 S MoPac Expy Bldg.1, Suite 300, Austin, TX 78746, United States
A good fit for
People reviewing auto and renters insurance togetherClients seeking help adding pet insurance

Cedar Oak Insurance is an Austin insurance agency that helps clients compare and arrange coverage. Its work includes auto, renters and pet insurance, with an emphasis on responsive guidance and finding solutions suited to a client’s situation. It is a fit for people who want one agent to help coordinate several personal insurance needs.

Contigo Insurance Agency, Austin#10
Strengths

  • Shops coverage and pricing across more than 30 Texas insurance companies

  • Handles personal, commercial vehicle, business and tax services

Contigo Insurance Agency

4.8211 reviews
9310 Georgian Dr Ste A, Austin, TX 78753, United States
A good fit for
Texas residents and businesses comparing insurance optionsPeople who want coverage terms explained in plain language

Contigo Insurance Agency is an independent Texas insurance broker offering auto, home, commercial vehicle, business and tax services. Its model is built around comparing coverage and pricing from more than 30 Texas insurance companies. The agency also explains Texas auto, homeowners and commercial coverage, helping clients understand terms such as liability, comprehensive and collision.

The key facts side by side

#BusinessRatingReviewsA good fit for
#1Abt Insurance Agency 5.0892People approaching Medicare eligibility or comparing Medicare options
#2Four Oaks Medicare Planning 5.0256People new to Medicare
#3GoMedigap 4.91,987People researching Medicare Supplement plans
#4Starr Insurance Agency 4.9251Customers comparing auto, home or umbrella coverage
#5Simple Retirement Benefits 5.099People evaluating Medicare Supplement or Advantage plans
#6Nemetz Insurance Services 4.9131Individuals comparing health insurance options
#7HealthMarkets Insurance 4.953Families comparing health insurance plans
#8Heaton Bennett Insurance 4.9981Austin households comparing auto or home coverage
#9Cedar Oak Insurance 4.9220People reviewing auto and renters insurance together
#10Contigo Insurance Agency 4.8211Texas residents and businesses comparing insurance options

Are you a business owner?

Manage my listing

Compare health insurance offices across Austin

The comparison includes Austin offices as well as one Buda agency and services described for Texas residents. Use the geographic context to weigh an Austin-based consultation against a nearby or broader-area option, then confirm where and how consultations are provided.

What these insurance offices can help with

  • Medicare plan comparisonGoMedigap, Four Oaks Medicare Planning, Abt Insurance Agency, and Simple Retirement Benefits help shoppers understand Medicare-related choices, including Supplement, Part D, Advantage, prescription coverage, or enrollment.
  • Enrollment and application guidanceSeveral offices describe step-by-step help with enrollment, paperwork, applications, or reviewing coverage changes.
  • Individual and family coverageHealthMarkets Insurance - Gabrielle Sones helps individuals and families compare options during coverage changes, with consultations available in an office or at home.
  • Personal and business insuranceHeaton Bennett Insurance and Contigo Insurance Agency address broader personal or commercial needs, including auto, home, business, commercial vehicle, and group health coverage.
  • Policy questions and adjustmentsStarr Insurance Agency supports quote questions, policy adjustments, and coordinated home, vehicle, and umbrella coverage.
  • Prescription, vision, and ancillary optionsNemetz Insurance Services assists with Medicare and ancillary plans such as prescription and vision coverage while explaining policy details.

Ways to narrow your Austin insurance search

  1. Start with the coverage categoryFor Medicare decisions, compare offices that explicitly discuss Supplement, Part D, Advantage, networks, or enrollment. For broader needs, look toward agencies listing personal or commercial coverage.
  2. Decide how much enrollment help you needIf forms, deadlines, or a first Medicare decision are central concerns, prioritize an office describing structured guidance through enrollment or application processing.
  3. Look for the communication style you preferSome businesses emphasize patient explanations and annual reviews, while others describe direct agent assistance, ongoing follow-up, or educational resources.
  4. Match the consultation settingPhone, online, office, and home-based options appear in the supplied descriptions. Confirm which format is available for your appointment.
  5. Ask what is actually being comparedBefore choosing, ask whether the discussion covers only Medicare or also prescription, vision, auto, home, commercial, or group health needs.

Questions people often ask

Which Austin offices focus on Medicare?

GoMedigap, Four Oaks Medicare Planning, Abt Insurance Agency, Nemetz Insurance Services, and Simple Retirement Benefits all describe Medicare-related guidance, with differing emphasis across Supplement, Part D, Advantage, prescription, network, or enrollment questions.

Can these offices help with enrollment paperwork?

Yes. GoMedigap, Four Oaks Medicare Planning, Abt Insurance Agency, and Nemetz Insurance Services describe enrollment or application assistance. Confirm the scope for your situation.

Are all of these businesses in Austin?

Most are described as Austin agencies or services. Nemetz Insurance Services is described as being in Buda, while Contigo Insurance Agency describes service for Texas residents and businesses.

Can I compare non-health insurance here?

Yes. Heaton Bennett, Starr, Cedar Oak, and Contigo describe auto, home, renters, umbrella, commercial, business, or other personal coverage. They may not fit Medicare-specific questions.

Related rankings

10 Best Business Banking Providers in Austin10 Best Insurance Offices in Austin10 Best Business Finance Providers in Austin